Posted on 01 December 2010.
Which one to use, a collar or a harness? Appears like a simple question until you are navigating your way through the local pet store.

The abundance of choices may appear overwhelming but the key is to grasp the purpose of each type of collar or harness. Just as each dog collar is not created the very same, each type does not fulfill the exact same preferences. When choosing a training device consider your dog’s training goals, size, health, energy level, and unique personality and characteristics. Below is a quick glance at the different styles of collars and harnesses for dogs.
Flat Collar – The variety of styles and sizes allows a bit of a personal touch to this tool. Flat collars are an important item for each and every dog or puppy because it enables them to wear their identification. The flat collar is an optimal walking option for healthy, well-trained, larger breed dogs. However, for dogs that pull or lunge on leash, the flat collar should be utilized solely for identification, versus a training tool or device.

Be aware that flat collars are safety tools as opposed to training tools due to the fact there is always an opportunity for injury. Injuries can include tracheal collapse and neck or spinal accidents. If your dog or puppy persistently has difficulty breathing while on leash, this indicates that your friend is pulling into the flat collar. This action could harm or injure your dog or puppy’s throat.
Head Collar – Head collars have straps that wrap around a dog’s snout and behind their head making their appearance seem like a muzzle. Unlike a muzzle, the head collar allows your pet the freedom of opening their mouth. Most dogs need to be conditioned to wear head collars so they are comfortable wearing prior to training in them.
The head collar is comparable to a horse’s halter. The head collar clips beneath the snout with the intention that whenever pressure is applied; the dog’s head will turn. Head collars are suggested as a walking device for dogs that pull or have other behavior issues including anxiety and aggression.
Body Harness, Back Clip – These tend to be safer for small breeds simply due to the potential of giving a leash correction that seriously injures the trachea is higher with a toy/small dog or a puppy wearing a flat collar. The back clip harness is also a good choice for dogs with previous neck or back injuries.
Some manufactures of this product may claim this device will stop your dog from pulling and lunging, Buyer beware because just the opposite is reality. A harness or back clip may inadvertently teach a canine to pull. Dogs can put their full weight into the back clip harness with no pain or discomfort.
Body Harness, Front Clip – The front clip harness serves a dual purpose. Similar to other harnesses, this style is often a useful alternative for smaller dogs, due to their susceptibility to tracheal collapse. The front clip harness may also be utilized as a management tool for ill-behaved dogs.
This device positions the clip for the leash at the center of your pet’s chest. The distinctive placement prevents them from utilizing their body weight to pull. If your pet lunges ahead, they will rapidly discover themselves turned towards you. When they are no longer permitted to lead the way, this will help to deter them from pulling on the leash.
Feel comfortable and confident as you depart from the pet store with your new training purchase. Choosing a collar or a harness is personal choice, but remember that living with and training a four legged friend can be a learning process for both of you. If your initial purchase choice is not working well for you or your pet do not hesitate to try a different training device. There are no “right” or “wrong” dog collars or harnesses so it is up to you to find the most “effective” training device to keep your pet healthy and safe for many years to come.